The timing couldn’t have appeared worse. North Korea announces it will launch a long-range rocket smack in the middle of a top Chinese envoy’s visit to Pyongyang. In diplomatic terms, it was yet another sign of disrespect for North Korea’s chief ally.
Adding to the indignity: The launch window for the rocket falls during the Lunar New Year, casting a shadow over China’s most important seasonal holiday.
The announcement again places China under pressure from the U.S. and others to use its influence with Pyongyang to rein in its communist neighbor, despite Beijing’s protestations that such influence is overestimated.
In Washington on Tuesday, top diplomat for East Asia Daniel Russel said a launch “would be an unmistakable slap in face to those who argue that you just need to show patience and dialogue with the North Koreans but not sanctions,” in an apparent reference to China.
Russel called for tough new sanctions, including what are believed to be a ban on selling the North oil or buying its minerals, excluding banks doing business with it from accessing the dollar-based economy, or even barring its flagship airline from entering other countries’ airspace.
Those are exactly the sort of regime-destabilizing steps that China fears, and Beijing, a veto-wielding permanent member of the United Nations Security Council appears to be pushing back. China already appears to be dragging its feet on a response to North Korea’s purported first H-bomb test on Jan. 6.
Following four hours of talks with U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry in Beijing last week, Foreign Minister Wang Yi reiterated China’s support for a tough new U.N. resolution but appeared to pour cold water on the idea of new penalties.
“Sanctions are not an end in themselves,” Wang said. “The new resolution should not provoke new tension in the situation, still less destabilize the Korean Peninsula.”
Chinese state media have been even blunter, laying the blame on Washington for provoking Pyongyang and accusing it of maintaining a “Cold War mentality.”
Sanctions have thus far included bans on weapon sales, dealing with blacklisted individuals or enterprises and other targeted measures. Although Beijing has supported those measures, it points to North Korea’s continuing nuclear tests and missile launches as proof of their ineffectiveness.
North Korea this week informed international organizations of its plans to launch an Earth observation satellite on a rocket between Feb. 8 and 25. The launch declaration, meant to warn civilians, shipping and aircraft in the area about the rocket and falling debris, follows North Korea’s disputed claim on Jan. 6 to have tested a hydrogen bomb, the country’s fourth nuclear test.
A visit by China’s chief North Korean envoy, Wu Dawei, to Pyongyang this week had been primarily an attempt to sound the North out on its intentions, and, as in the past, Beijing was probably not informed of the announcement beforehand, said Liu Ming, an specialist in Korean issues at the Shanghai Academy of Social Sciences
North Korea’s most important ally, chief trading partner and a key source of economic assistance, China may adopt limited unilateral steps to express its dissatisfaction, including stepped inspections on North Korean ships docking in China and reducing oil exports.
Those steps could show China is taking action, although support for tough new U.N. sanctions remains unlikely, Liu said.
“In order to maintain a normal relationship, China won’t adopt all-around sanctions against North Korea. To do so would plunge the relationship into a hostile state and China is unwilling to go as far as that,” Liu said.
So far, China’s entirely state-controlled media has provided only limited coverage of the North’s announcement and remained mum on Wu’s mission, possibly to limit the effect on public opinion that has grown increasingly critical of Pyongyang.
China has strong historical, political and financial concerns that factor into its opposition to sanctions that could undermine or even topple reclusive leader Kim Jong Un’s hardline communist regime.
China fought against South Korea, the U.S. and their allies in the 1950-53 Korean War and, for years, described their relationship as being “as close as lips and teeth.” Beijing fears that political turmoil could send refugees streaming across the border into northeastern China and, ultimately, see U.S. troops occupying what it sees as a crucial buffer with South Korea, where 28,000 troops are based as a legacy of the war that ended with a truce, not a peace treaty.
Additionally, Chinese state companies, private businesses and financial institutions are the chiefly beneficiaries of other countries’ shunning North Korea, dealing in fields from tourism to mineral extraction. Harsher measures would affect their bottom line, along with the economy along 1,420-kilometer Chinese-North Korean border.
Still, China’s patience with North Korea’s snubs and provocations has its limits, said Jin Linbo, a Korea expert at the China Institute of International Studies.
Jin said China would like to try additional steps before tough sanctions are imposed, mainly using inducements to persuade the North to return to six-nation nuclear disarmament talks hosted by Beijing that have been stalled since 2009.
However, if North Korea insists on pushing ahead, “there will be no reason for China to persuade other countries to mitigate the sanctions,” Jin said.
“The space remaining for China to maneuver diplomatically will become smaller and smaller and the possibilities for China to help North Korea will become fewer and fewer.” Christopher Bodeen, Beijing, AP
No Comments