Detained activist begins final appeal for recognition of his overseas same-sex marriage
Detained activist Jimmy Sham leaves a prison van to enter the Court of Final Appeal
An activist detained in Hong Kong began his final appeal yesterday seeking recognition for his same-sex marriage registered overseas, in a landmark case for the city’s LGBTQ+ community.
Jimmy Sham, a prominent pro-democracy activist during 2019, first asked for a judicial review five years ago seeking a declaration that the city’s laws, which do not recognize foreign same-sex marriage, violate his constitutional right to equality. But the lower courts dismissed his legal challenge and a subsequent appeal over the case.
Sham is now in custody after being charged with subversion over an unofficial primary election under a national security law.
The upcoming judgment by the city’s top court in his marriage case will have strong implications for the lives of the LGBTQ+ community and the financial hub’s reputation as an inclusive place to live and work.
Currently, the city only recognizes same-sex marriage for certain purposes such as taxation, civil service benefits and dependent visas. Many of the government’s concessions were won through legal challenges over the last few years.
The court will have to address whether the exclusion of same-sex couples from the institution of marriage and a failure to provide alternative means of legal recognition for same-sex partnerships violate the right to equality. The judges will also have to decide if the city’s laws violate that right enshrined in Hong Kong’s constitution, as they do not recognize foreign same-sex marriage.
Yesterday, Sham appeared spirited inside the courtroom.
His lawyer Karon Monaghan argued that the absence of same-sex marriage in Hong Kong sent a message that it is less worthy of recognition than heterosexual marriage.
Sham and his husband married in New York in 2013. They wished to marry in Hong Kong but it was not allowed under the law, according to previous judgments.
The ruling in 2020 said his marriage lacks essential validity because the city’s law does not permit marriage between same-sex persons. It added that Sham’s attempt to achieve complete parity of recognition between foreign same-sex marriages and foreign heterosexual marriages is “too ambitious.”
Sham’s appeal over the case was also dismissed last August.
Sham is the former convenor of Civil Human Rights Front, which was best known for organizing the annual march on the anniversary of Hong Kong’s handover to Chinese rule on July 1, 1997, for years. The group also organized some of the bigger political protests in 2019.
The front was disbanded in 2021 as it reportedly faces a police investigation for possible violation of the security law.
In February, the top court ruled that full sex reassignment surgery should not be a prerequisite for transgender people to have their gender changed on their official identity cards. Supporters said it was an important milestone for the transgender community in Hong Kong. MDT/AP
