The Epicentre of Scotch II

(Continued from “The Epicentre of Scotch” on 14 September 2018)

Not for nothing is scotch hailed as the gentleman’s drink, or indeed compared to the making of a gentleman. Even if free of any defect, the birth of the baby (new-make spirit) guarantees no excellence, which has to be attained through years if not decades of education (barrel maturation). Whisky is much less affected by terroirs and vintages than is wine, but its focus on barrel maturation is like no other, perhaps rivalled only by brandy, which arguably requires less maturation than does whisky.

Scotch distilleries make use of a kaleidoscopic range of barrels, be it ex-bourbon (the standard) or ex-sherry (the main niche), or indeed barrels wherein armagnac, beer, cognac, madeira, marsala, port, rum or various types of wine have been matured. By some accounts, a common 600l barrel is said to have absorbed and still contain in its wooden texture10-20l of the nectar it once held, hence the flavours it imparts on the whisky.

Whether the barrel is used to mature whisky for the first time (first-fill), second time (second-fill) or for multiple times does affect the taste of the final product; understandably, the influence of the barrel decreases as the number of fills increases. Meanwhile, how and when the barrel is used, i.e. whether at the maturing or marrying or finishing stage, is of key importance.

Barrel size is a crucial factor, as complicated as the myriads of terroirs in wine. As a rule of thumb, the smaller the barrel, the more contact with wood. More like a football pitch than tennis court, barrel sizes are not exact but within certain ranges. The names of the barrels do give indication to their sizes, but hard to understand, as most are 18th century British English and use the imperial system.

In descending order according to volume, common types of barrels used in scotch production include: i) 700l ex-bourbon gordas made from American oak; ii) 650l ex-madeira drums and ex-port pipes made from European oak; iii) 500l ex-sherry butts made from European oak; iv) 225-300l ex-brandy or -wine barriques made from American or European oak; v) 200-225l ex-bourbon hogshead made from American oak; and vi) the relatively new invention of 125l quarter casks, usually built specifically for whisky.

Speyside is well-known for its masterful use of ex-sherry barrels, ranging from fino and oloroso to pedro ximémez, to produce aromatic and rich, full-bodied and dark-coloured whiskies. For all its visibility, this style of whisky remains a niche in the world of scotch, as the vast of majority continues to be matured in ex-bourbon barrels.

Glenlivet French Oak Reserve 15 Years Old

Bright amber with citrine-golden reflex, the fragrantly vinous nose offers brown raisin, cinnamon, chestnut, crème brûlée and cedar. With a rounded mouthfeel, the richly spiced palate delivers sweet ginger, nutmeg, almond, apple crumble and charred wood. Medium-full bodied at 40%, the arboreal entry continues through a tangy mid-palate, leading to warm finish. An innovative dram that instils the charm of wine into the spirit of scotch.

BenRiach 16 Years Old

Luminous jonquil with scintillating golden reflex, the alluringly intricate nose presents tangerine, green almond, shortbread, nougat and white smoke. With a creamy mouthfeel, the complex yet structured palate furnishes physalis, pine nuts, roasted barley, salted toffee and light peat. Medium-full bodied at 43%, the composed entry persists through a chiselled mid-palate, leading to a lingering finish. A very fine dram to be savoured during or after dinner.

Glenrothes Vintage 1995 – Bottled in 2015

Saturated golden with brilliant amber reflex, the spellbinding nose effuses dried coconut shreds, dried basil, nutmeg, crème brûlée, gingerbread and cedar. With a buttery mouthfeel, the mesmerising palate emanates dried apricot, sweet ginger, cocoa, salted fudge, marzipan and bonfire smoke. Full-bodied at 43%, the poised entry evolves into a multifarious mid-palate, leading to an urbane finish. An absolute showstopper, an operatic experience in a bottle.


Jacky I.F. Cheong is a legal professional by day and columnist by night. Having spent his formative years in Britain, France,
and Germany, he regularly writes about wine, fine arts, classical music, and politics in several languages

Categories World of Bacchus