Thai-US | Tensions test as strategic bilateral relations talks resume

U.S. Assistant Secretary of State for East Asian and Pacific Affairs Daniel Russel

The top U.S. envoy for East Asia returns to military-governed Thailand this week, hoping for better press than on his last visit a year ago. Local media branded veteran diplomat Daniel Russel an “ugly American” and the government protested that he had “wounded the hearts of Thais” for publicly criticizing its curbs on democracy.
Russel is traveling to Bangkok for the first formal U.S.-Thai strategic dialogue since the May 2014 coup. That is part of a broader Obama administration effort to build stronger U.S. ties in Southeast Asia and counter China’s rise. But the underlying problems remain. The Thai military keeps delaying a return to civilian rule, and Washington keeps falling afoul of Thailand’s hyper-sensitive politics.
Police recently took up a complaint brought by hard-line royalists who accused the U.S. Ambassador to Thailand, Glyn Davies, of defaming the monarchy after he voiced concern about long prison sentences under a law that criminalizes criticism of the royal family. That reflects broader U.S. concerns about the junta’s clampdown on dissent.
Police appear unlikely to pursue an investigation against Davies, who has diplomatic immunity. But the adverse response he provoked, despite prefacing his remarks with praise of Thailand’s revered King Bhumibol Adulyadej, underscored the disconnect that increasingly weighs on America’s oldest diplomatic relationship in Asia.
“The military is convinced that it saved Thailand from spiraling into chaos and acts hurt and puzzled that Washington doesn’t understand this,” said Murray Hiebert, an expert on Southeast Asia at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. “The current flap is another sign of how much bilateral relations have deteriorated since the coup.”
Desmond Wilson, a former U.S. defense attache in Bangkok who criticized Washington’s post-coup scaling back of ties, said the strategic dialogue — last held in 2012 — showed the U.S. is shifting toward a more pragmatic approach. He predicted that Wednesday’s talks between the two foreign ministries would be followed by a high-level military dialogue early next year.
The U.S.-Thai diplomatic relationship dates back 182 years. Today, Thailand is less critical to American interests than it was during the Vietnam War, when it hosted 50,000 U.S. forces, but it remains a regional hub for the U.S. on issues like intelligence, law enforcement and counter-narcotics. Although the U.S. has restricted military assistance since the coup, Thailand continues to host America’s largest multilateral military exercises in the Asia-Pacific.
The Thai Ambassador to the U.S., Pisan Manawapat, said that the U.S. and Thailand have shared interests in the region, and hoped the strategic dialogue would elevate bilateral relations. “The U.S. knows well how to deal with its friends and allies in order to bring about shared outcomes,” he said.
Russel said that the two governments should “maximize our cooperation within the bounds of what’s possible under current circumstances.” But he said the U.S. wouldn’t “walk away” from its commitment to universal values like free speech.
“What ultimately is going to matter is that this story ends well,” said Russel. “My primary concern is that the Thai nation emerges from this period of military rule with a stable, democratic, civilian-led, inclusive government.”
Thailand has been consumed by political turmoil for the past decade, since the military ousted populist but divisive leader Thaksin Shinawatra in 2006, sparking intermittent bouts of unrest and bloodshed between Thaksin supporters and pro-establishment opponents. On his January visit, Russel stirred a furor because he met with the prime minister ousted in the latest coup, Thaksin’s sister Yingluck, and said in a speech that her parliamentary impeachment was politically motivated.
Russel is not expected to meet Yingluck this week, but will confer with political leaders, including from the opposition.
The political atmosphere has only grown tenser in recent months as the Thai economy has flagged and concern grows over the health of King Bhumibol, a stabilizing force during his seven decades on the throne. Many analysts predict the military will be reluctant to make way for a new civilian government until Bhumibol’s successor is in place.
Lese majeste cases have multiplied, with some people receiving sentences of more than 25 years for anti-royal comments on the Internet, amid signs the draconian law is being wielded to check political dissent.
The military has postponed elections until at least 2017. While that is straining Thailand’s relations with the U.S., ties with China have deepened. For the first time last month, Thailand and China held a joint air force exercise.
But getting cozy with Beijing carries reputational costs for Bangkok. Thailand has drawn international condemnation for deporting Uighur Muslim migrants and U.N.-registered refugees back to China.
John Sifton, Asia policy director of Human Rights Watch, said Thailand’s rights record has worsened in several ways, including repression of civil society. He called for the U.S. to keep restrictions on relations until Thailand restores democracy.
“Unfortunately, some governments have determined they have to do business diplomatically with Thailand because the junta is here to stay. But if there’s no penalty for staying in power and abusing human rights, what motivation will force the junta to change course?” he said. Matthew Pennington, Washington,AP