NIMBY or pension: Australia pops the data center bubble


Shuli Ren, Bloomberg
Not in my backyard or in my retirement fund. Australia is giving us a chilling preview of how fast the trillion-dollar AI data center buildout can unwind.
Builders are planning to add around 23 gigawatts of compute capacity, up from just 6 gigawatts in February, according to the Commonwealth Bank of Australia. The country is seen as a prime destination: It’s priced competitively — rental rates in Sydney are half of those in Singapore — and the biggest cities have more space.
But odds are that most of these won’t materialize. Local communities are increasingly vocal, and successful pushback by one emboldens campaigning by others.
In late September, Goodman Group scrapped a plan to build a 90-megawatt facility in a Sydney suburb. In early October, Firmus Grid Ltd.’s 288-megawatt Bell Bay site in Tasmania was hit with appeals just weeks after receiving local council approval.
Then the most damaging news came last week. Data center manager Nextdc Ltd. slashed its earnings forecast and placed development plans for one of its major facilities in Melbourne on hold. Electricity provider Jemena had suspended work to deliver more power to the M3 facility because of local opposition to the installation of 22-meter-high power poles. Now the company’s best hope is that Jemena will recommence work in February.
Only about one-third of planned developments in the pipeline can be delivered by 2030, according to Goldman Sachs Group Inc. Nextdc’s M4 facility, also in Melbourne, for instance, has only a 13% chance of success, according to Goldman. The 150-megawatt campus is facing fierce backlash from residents.
Project withdrawals have occurred at all stages. The median probability of a development progressing from its current status to completion is only 28%, according to the CBA, using data from the Australian Energy Market Operator. In some ways, these builders resemble biotech firms, risking vast sums of money to develop one product, only to have nothing to show for it in the end.
From data center hotspot to unexpected failures, a drastic shift in Australia’s business conditions perhaps explains why capital markets have reacted so violently. Firmus had to pull a much-anticipated initial public offering in October despite being a venture capital darling just two months earlier. Similarly, Nextdc’s A$1.1 billion ($773 million) convertible bond, issued in September at a meager 1.75% coupon, is now yielding a whopping 12%. Nextdc’s shares have tumbled more than 40% since the hybrid’s issue.
UniSuper, one of Australia’s top pension funds, decided not to participate in Firmus’ IPO and is steering clear of direct investments in data centers. In hindsight, it’s a good call.
Rather, it’s clear by now that having permits alone doesn’t necessarily give developers the social license to operate. Going forward, we need to look at each project separately — including its location, timing, financing and local political dynamics — before saying with confidence that it will be a cash-generating asset. Are investors prepared to get their hands dirty?
Commenting on Firmus’ IPO, UniSuper’s Chief Investment Officer John Pearce noted that bankers and vendors all got a bit greedy and that the share price would have been “probably closer to $1 than $11.” Indeed, it’s easy for these unicorns to lose their shirt over opposition from a tightly knit community. Their business model is not only capital intensive, but precarious.
[Abridged]
Courtesy Bloomberg/Shuli Ren
Leave a reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.

























