MACAU DAILY TIMES 澳門每日時報

Top Menu

  • Our Team
  • Editorial Statute
    • Code of Ethics
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
  • Archive
    • PDF Editions
  • Contacts
  • Extra Times
    • Drive In
    • Book It
    • tTunes
    • Features
    • World of Bacchus
    • Taste of Edesia

Main Menu

  • Home
  • Macau
    • Photo Shop
    • Advertorial
  • Interview
  • Greater Bay
  • Business
    • Corporate Bits
  • China
  • Asia
  • World
  • Sports
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Our Desk
    • Business Views
    • China Daily
    • Multipolar World
    • The Conversation
    • World Views
  • Our Team
  • Editorial Statute
    • Code of Ethics
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
  • Archive
    • PDF Editions
  • Contacts
  • Extra Times
    • Drive In
    • Book It
    • tTunes
    • Features
    • World of Bacchus
    • Taste of Edesia
logo
FOUNDER & PUBLISHER Kowie Geldenhuys
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF Paulo Coutinho
Macau,

MACAU DAILY TIMES 澳門每日時報

  • Home
  • Macau
    • Photo Shop
    • Advertorial
  • Interview
  • Greater Bay
  • Business
    • Corporate Bits
  • China
  • Asia
  • World
  • Sports
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Our Desk
    • Business Views
    • China Daily
    • Multipolar World
    • The Conversation
    • World Views
  • Xi backs global bay area association and calls for freer Asia-Pacific trade

  • President Marcos Jr has Jollibee fried chicken delivered to Trump for a late-night snack

  • Han Lichao leads GBA GT Cup contenders

  • Policy Address leaves civil service pay unchanged despite calls for rise

  • Miss International an ‘opportunity to promote Macau’s cultural heritage and identity,’ says Ariel Tan

  • When AI fails, a notebook still works

Macau
Home›Macau›Courts | IPIM: Prosecutors said to muster only ‘irrelevant and circumstantial’ evidence

Courts | IPIM: Prosecutors said to muster only ‘irrelevant and circumstantial’ evidence

By Renato Marques, MDT
Wednesday, August 12, 2020
113
0

This courtroom sketch shows lawyers Icília Berenguel (left) and Jorge Ho (right) deliver closing statements, while defendant Jackson Chang looks on

The defense lawyers for 26 people allegedly connected to an unlawful residency application scheme at the Macao Trade and Investment Promotion Institute (IPIM) agree on one aspect of the case above all. They all consider that the Public Prosecutions Office (MP) has not been able to prove the large majority, if any, of the facts used to try the defendants.
The assertion first asserted on Monday by the legal representatives of the first two defendants. This continued yesterday, with defense lawyers presenting evidence suggesting that the MP was making speculative and circumstantial accusations.
This was also the stance of lawyer Pedro Leal, who is representing former executive director of IPIM, Glória Batalha Ung.
Starting with a humorous remark, the lawyer said he was pleased by the fact that the previous day’s accusations had dedicated very little time and attention to his client’s case. He explained that can only mean that the accusations aimed at the former executive director were not that serious or important, and that the accusations against her were weak.
Leal then started to dismantle the theory of the accusations. He said that “even the irrelevant and circumstantial evidence brought to the trial by the MP should not be validated by the court.”
The lawyer explained that the crimes that Batalha was being accused of were semi-public. This means that in order to be investigated and constitute reason for an accusation, they depend on a prior and formal complaint from a person or entity which the object of the crime is related to. In this case, the investigation would depend on a formal complaint by the IPIM leadership or its immediate superior, the Secretary for Economy and Finance.
According to Leal, this did not occur until very late in the process. The MP then justified this using a letter from IPIM. In the letter however, IPIM claims that it is not aware of any wrongdoing or evidence that might constitute a crime by Batalha.
“This is not a formal complaint and a request for Batalha to be investigated. This is an acknowledgment of ignorance of any facts that could indicate crime,” Leal said. He added that the letter also came on December 12, 2018, almost two months after the investigation into Batalha had officially started.
The lawyer proposed that this was enough of a reason for the evidence collected before the date of the IPIM letter to be disregarded by the court, though this did not occur.
Leal said that an unfair investigation that results in an unfair result is like a “poisonous tree that gives poisonous fruits.”
The lawyer continued to show why he disagreed with the theory of the crimes which his client was being accused of, as he had done in several prior court sessions. He quoted several experts on law and penal code interpretation to show that Batalha’s alleged assistance in reviewing application requirements before the applications were formally submitted should not be considered as a breach of secrecy.
Instead, they should have been seen as part of her normal duties and competencies at work. This reasoning led him to refute the second part of the accusations which included abuse of power.
The lawyer recalled that the crime of breach of secrecy depends on intentionality and must produce benefits or prejudice to someone, highlighting that both intentionality and the benefits or losses from the act could not be proven in any way.
While calling for Batalha to be acquitted of all crimes, Leal also had time to criticize what he called an “awful addiction” of the Commission Against Corruption (CCAC) and the Judiciary Police, which issued press statements on cases before the investigations concluded and before the suspects were accused of any crimes.
For Leal, this “bad culture” often results in enormous prejudice against the defendants and clashes with the essential right of “presumption of innocence.”
Giving an example, Leal said that when trying to use her credit card to pay the bill for a birthday celebration, Batalha was informed by the restaurant that the card had been rejected. According to the bank, she had been stopped from using the card as she was involved in corruption, despite this being unproven and a crime that she was not actually being accused of.
“For the banks, she had already been sentenced for a crime that she was never even accused of,” Leal said.
Also in yesterday’s court session, the lawyer of Miguel Ian Iat Chun, Jorge Ho, claimed that the whole accusation was unfounded and that the defendant should also be acquitted of all charges.
According to Ho, aside from misinterpreting IPIM’s procedures and purposes, the MP did not present any conclusive evidence of Ian’s alleged participation in a criminal association.
In fact, the defense lawyers for all defendants acknowledged that this criminal association could not exist as there was not any legal basis to sustain the theory.
Like Leal, Ho also mentioned that this case had caused Ian to lose his job and his family lost its income.
In the long sequence that followed, all the lawyers mentioned the lack of proof for the accusations. Highlights included Leong Mio Na, who is defending Ng Kuok Sao and Ieong Sok Chun, and Icília Berenguel, who is defending Angela Ip. They explained why the theories of the accusation were poorly substantiated and fell apart easily when tested.
Leong noted that Ng never founded any criminal organization and that the only relationship between Ng and other people accused of being part of the organization were simply normal relations between the boss, his wife and employees of the One Kin Construction Company, one of the companies Ng owns.
Lei Sin U, another lawyer, also insisted that the relationship between Ng, his wife Wu Sok Wah, and the employees were simple employment relationships where staff were obligated to fulfill tasks delegated by the boss.
Criticizing the way the prosecution insisted on the accusations despite the lack of proof, Lei said, “It seems that the CCAC investigators took their conclusions about what they found or hinted and then the MP just certified that without paying enough attention to the cases.”
Berenguel also referred to the “emptiness of accusations,” saying that over the past two months she assisted with surprise to the lack of confirmation of any of the array of accusations by the MP.

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • Print (Opens in new window) Print

Like this:

Like Loading…

Related

Previous Article

Appreciating nature through music | Macao Orchestra ...

Next Article

Tourism sector abuzz after visa resumption in ...

Related articles More from author

  • HeadlinesMacau

    Gaming industry groups protest for salary increases

    Tuesday, January 10, 2017
    By Julie Zhu, MDT
  • Macau

    71st Macau Grand Prix Winners List

    Monday, November 18, 2024
    By -
  • HeadlinesMacau

    Testimonies confirm Tak Chun involved in side betting

    Tuesday, December 6, 2022
    By Anthony Lam, MDT
  • Macau

    Locals occupy 90% of gaming industry managerial jobs

    Monday, September 16, 2024
    By -
  • Macau

    Sands China announces profits of MOP1.5b in Q2

    Friday, July 21, 2023
    By Renato Marques, MDT
  • HeadlinesMacau

    CTM expects future concession contracts to be ‘tougher’

    Wednesday, September 7, 2016
    By Renato Marques, MDT

Leave a reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • China

    China watchdog weighs letting US inspect company audits: report

  • Business

    Gaming – Japan | Ex-minister denies receiving China money in alleged bribery case

  • Macau

    Kong Chi faces 21 years in prison for corruption charges

DAILY EDITION

Thursday, November 19, 2026 – edition no. 5079
Thursday, November 19, 2026 – edition no. 5079

Greater Bay

MDT MACAU GRAND PRIX SPECIAL

November 2026
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  
« Oct    

Timeline

  • Thursday, November 19, 2026

    Xi backs global bay area association and calls for freer Asia-Pacific trade

  • Thursday, November 19, 2026

    President Marcos Jr has Jollibee fried chicken delivered to Trump for a late-night snack

  • Thursday, November 19, 2026

    Han Lichao leads GBA GT Cup contenders

  • Thursday, November 19, 2026

    Policy Address leaves civil service pay unchanged despite calls for rise

  • Thursday, November 19, 2026

    Miss International an ‘opportunity to promote Macau’s cultural heritage and identity,’ says Ariel Tan

  • Thursday, November 19, 2026

    When AI fails, a notebook still works

  • Thursday, November 19, 2026

    Consumer complaints rise 26% to 5,654 in first nine months

  • Thursday, November 19, 2026

    Gov’t addresses ageing and low birth rate with volunteers, carer support and childcare subsidies

  • Thursday, November 19, 2026

    Community spending scheme extends to Grand Prix, food festival

  • Thursday, November 19, 2026

    Bus route 32T to operate on weekends during food festivaL

Extra Times

Extra TimesHeadlinesTaste of Edesia

Three chefs. One horizon. Six Michelin stars

There are moments when separate culinary philosophies align so precisely that the result transcends mere menu-making. At Chef Tam’s Seasons, Wynn Palace, three two-Michelin-starred titans—each ranked among Asia’s 50 Best ...
  • James Gray delivers a milestone crime drama in ‘Paper Tiger’

    By MDT/AP
    Friday, November 13, 2026
  • The Twelve25 × La Vie exchange

    By -
    Friday, November 13, 2026
  • A fiery milestone: Feng Wei Ju’s 20th anniversary tribute to Starworld Macau

    By Irene Sam, MDT
    Friday, November 6, 2026
  • In ‘I Play Rocky,’ a middleweight crowd-pleaser about the making of a classic

    By MDT/AP
    Friday, November 6, 2026
  • Recent

  • Popular

  • Xi backs global bay area association and calls for freer Asia-Pacific trade

    By Times Reporter
    Thursday, November 19, 2026
  • President Marcos Jr has Jollibee fried chicken delivered to Trump for a ...

    By -
    Thursday, November 19, 2026
  • Han Lichao leads GBA GT Cup contenders

    By Renato Marques, MDT
    Thursday, November 19, 2026
  • Policy Address leaves civil service pay unchanged despite calls for rise

    By Yuki Lei, MDT
    Thursday, November 19, 2026
  • Miss International an ‘opportunity to promote Macau’s cultural heritage and identity,’ says Ariel Tan

    By Renato Marques, MDT
    Thursday, November 19, 2026
  • When AI fails, a notebook still works

    By Nadia Shaw, MDT
    Thursday, November 19, 2026
  • Consumer complaints rise 26% to 5,654 in first nine months

    By Times Reporter
    Thursday, November 19, 2026
  • Canidrome may have its days numbered, decision in ‘one or two months’

    By Paulo Coutinho, MDT
    Thursday, May 26, 2016
  • Animal Welfare | Macau: Anima slams Canidrome management for avoiding debate

    By -
    Wednesday, May 4, 2016
  • Editorial | Canidoomed

    By Paulo Coutinho, MDT
    Wednesday, June 1, 2016
  • Animal Welfare | Canidrome presented with ultimatum: close or move

    By Daniel Beitler, MDT
    Friday, July 22, 2016
  • Australia regulator cracks down on alleged exportation of dogs to Macau

    By Paulo Coutinho, MDT
    Friday, June 10, 2016
  • Animal rights | Canidrome: Anima in fresh airline negotiations as Canidrome closure looks more likely

    By Daniel Beitler, MDT
    Friday, May 27, 2016
  • USE OF ENGLISH IN MACAU | A ‘de facto’ official language

    By Catarina Pinto
    Monday, July 6, 2015
  • Contact our Administrator
  • Contact our Editor-in-Chief
  • Contacts
  • Our Team
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Editorial Statute
  • Code of Ethics
COPYRIGHT © MACAU DAILY TIMES 2008-2026. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
MACAU DAILY TIMES
  • Home
  • Macau
    • Photo Shop
    • Advertorial
  • Interview
  • Greater Bay
  • Business
    • Corporate Bits
  • China
  • Asia
  • World
  • Sports
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Our Desk
    • Business Views
    • China Daily
    • Multipolar World
    • The Conversation
    • World Views
  • Our Team
  • Editorial Statute
    • Code of Ethics
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
  • Archive
    • PDF Editions
  • Contacts
  • Extra Times
    • Drive In
    • Book It
    • tTunes
    • Features
    • World of Bacchus
    • Taste of Edesia
Loading Comments...

You must be logged in to post a comment.

%d