International integration: the push-me pull-you of talent

AI-Generated Illustration

ANALYSIS

The State Council Information Office – and other official media outlets – reported on 30th March on the 2026 Macao International Parade. The Office’s focus was on the theme of the Maritime Silk Road as a bridge for cultural exchange. They expanded on the concept of “love, peace and cultural integration” embodied by the performing groups representing countries and regions along the Maritime Silk Road. The symbolism of Macau’s role historically as a bridge between China and the outside world – its openness to cultural diversity and integration – is well leveraged to impress upon the Macau community its future role in integration with the mother country via the bridge of Hengqin.

There has been a concerted drive over the last few years to encourage Macau youth to explore potential for their future in the GBA, commencing with the Macao Youth Internship Program that offers structured internships in the Guangdong-Macao In-Depth Cooperation Zone in Hengqin.

A partnership between Macau’s Labour Affairs Bureau and Hengqin’s Livelihood Affairs Bureau, this year an expanded program offers 200 internships across multiple sectors featuring five specialised tracks. The outcomes are aimed to encourage Macau youth to develop relationships through exchanges beyond the glitz of the gaming industry, to create a sense of identity with the GBA, and build longer-term talent circulation between Macau and the GBA.

Young Macau adults working in mainland China are also being offered subsidies both online and through promotional activities, university career days and job fairs in Guangdong. This is a Macau-Mainland youth employment incentive open for application between October 2025 and September 2026 by the Education and Youth Development Bureau in cooperation with the Labour Affairs Bureau.

Incentives vs. market gravity

The program tops up remuneration for work and gives other incentives to young Macao tertiary graduates under the age of 35 to work full-time in nine GBA cities or Hengqin with a select list of employers. With the stated aim of easing youth unemployment in Macau (which stood at 6.7% in 2024 for 16–24-year-olds) and to strengthen integration in the GBA it offers a subsidy of MOP5,000 per month for up to 18 months.

Monthly housing rental support, special housing units set aside for young “GBA talent,” incubation and training programs, and cross-border commuter transport subsidies are available in Zhuhai, Guangzhou and Shenzhen. Career development programs training and mentorship are also included. The long-term aim is to diversify Macau’s economy by offering young people experience in sectors such as tech industries and finance, strengthen the cross-border workforce and reduce pressure on the Macau job market.

More recently, the “million talents” job fair was held in Guangzhou on the 15th and 16th March. Nearly 2,000 employers with 85,000 jobs attracted 170,000 job seekers from across and beyond the province. From the Cooperation Zone in Hengqin were 22 enterprises, providing nearly 500 job vacancies in finance, biomed, and technological innovation.

Indicative of the substantial resources being invested in promotion of the Cooperation Zone for the youth of Macau, a high-level mission of officials from the zone carried with them the message of Hengqin being where “industry is prosperous, life is good and close to Macau. A great place to start a business, to live and to work.”

There is a balancing act between the needs of integration and human development, and the needs of the Macau labour market; one that requires careful consideration of sectors already finding difficulties hiring skilled and talented young people locally. Recently, the Macau Insurers’ Association announced at the 2026 Macao Industry and Commerce Forum that the insurance sector is facing a critical shortage of professional talent, thus curbing growth and internationalisation.

Labour shortages at home, talent gaps abroad

The association called for non-local tertiary graduates to be able to remain in Macau after their studies to help fix the current and forecast workforce shortages and to improve overall skill levels with locally educated workers familiar with Macau.

Already the industry is experiencing a lowering of hiring standards as some firms are relaxing their requirements for professional certification. An added bonus of this graduate workforce is that these students come with networks in neighbouring and from international regions to facilitate business expansion.

With 2026 February unemployment at 1.7%, Macau employers often struggle to recruit, particularly in hospitality, retail, healthcare and now in insurance services. The banking sector in the third quarter 2025 had an employee recruitment rate of 4.6%, growing by 0.4 percentage points. This reflected a rise in demand for manpower in the Banking Sector with increasing job vacancies (3.4%, increasing by 1.3 percentage points).

The problems of a tight labour market include the lowering of quality standards and training requirements and systemic mediocrity of a workforce who have been under-incentivized by lack of competition. Studies repeatedly show that skilled immigration boosts innovation, increases brain-gain, decreases brain loss, increases productivity, economic growth, and offers new perspectives.

There is also eventually a benefit to migrants’ home regions, as the skills, networks, capital, trade and investment linkages eventually lead to brain gain as the graduated workers return home thus increasing the stock of educated workers.

This is particularly pertinent for Portuguese-speaking trade and global cooperation through international students from Portuguese-speaking countries. A study out of the University of Michigan offers evidence that migration opportunities create positive feedback loops for all involved.

Competition, reform and the education lever

Job vacancy rates tell a more nuanced story of Macau. As a benchmark, the OECD countries sit at around 2-3%. Anything under 2% suggests a tight labour market with potential difficulty for employers hiring, putting upwards pressure on salaries and wages, and – tangentially – often putting pressure and stress on staff (experienced by many Macau professionals), sometimes leading to burnout.

Vacancy rates above 5% – especially when above the unemployment rate – suggests a qualitative issue of a mismatch between the requirements of vacant positions and the qualifications of available applicants. There will likely be delays in filling roles, a loss of productivity, and skills and talent scarcity. Other explanations suggest the industry segment or company has poor employer branding or is highly specialised.

Currently in Macau we see high vacancy rates and – statistically – potential talent and willingness mismatches in the following areas: professionals in the gaming industry (4.9% vacancy rate in Q4 2025), non-bank Financial Intermediation (a 5.5% vacancy rate, Q3 2025 figures), Retail trade (5.6%, Q4) Transport, storage and communication (6.2%, Q4), Security activities (8%, Q4) and Insurance (4.4%, Q3).

In September 2025, average earnings of full-time employees in Financial Activities were MOP32,460, up by 2.0% year-on-year. Average earnings in the Banking Sector and Insurance Activities stood at MOP32,680 (+1.8%) and MOP34,810 (+2.9%) respectively – the latter is where we are hearing screams from the sector.

Granted, not all these positions at these rates are accessible to new graduates, but even, as an example, at the average December rates of remuneration in the Wholesale & Retail Trade, one of the least remunerated sectors which stood at MOP14,640, it is difficult for GBA jobs to compete with Macau’s salaries and wages, even with the incentivising subsidies.

Integration by local Macau residents into the GBA is to be encouraged – for it is there where many young people will gain an understanding of a competitive working environment and will build invaluable skills and a mindset of excellence in doing so. Macau’s tight labour market depicted in these numbers and generous payment packages and protectionist labour policies suggest uptake of these incentives may be an uphill battle if some of the other potential push factors are not dealt with.

The canary in the gold-mine call by the insurance industry warning of unsustainable structural, policy and normative elements in workforce culture and practices, recognises that incorporating some form of controlled competition into the labour force or competitive mindset in our youth might be a little uncomfortable in the short-term but far less damaging than an ill-equipped mismatched Macau workforce for the future of the GBA.

As lobbied in these pages back in 2011, there is another step further along the route of introducing gradual competitive reform among our youth. Education is the industry that will deliver the most valuable resource to any service- or innovation-based economy – skilled, knowledgeable and motivated human resources. Macau would attract a greater number and higher calibre of non-local students if they could be allowed, not only to work after graduation, but to do a specified number of hours of part-time work during their studies.

International students could apply what they learn at university to their part-time work, and then share their workplace experiences back into the classroom.

They develop a deeper understanding of our culture, styles of communication, laws and institutions, as well as building lasting and profound relationships by actively contributing to our community – these networks spillover into career pathways and international collaborative opportunities. With this increase in quality and energy, the entire university campus is invigorated, and our local students benefit from that competitive edge – it lifts everyone’s game, ready for the GBA. By Leanda Lee