In Taiwan, Mainland-born spouses face questions of loyalty, and discrimination

Li Chen-hsiu speaks during an interview in Taoyuan [AP Photo]

The day after Li Chen-hsiu was sworn in as a member of Taiwan’s Legislature, she was questioned about whether she belonged — about her nationality, about her identity and ultimately about her loyalty to Taiwan.

That’s because Li is a “mainland spouse” — born in mainland China and a citizen of Taiwan through marriage. She’s part of a community of some 369,000 people on the island who are subject to rapidly changing policies — and some say discrimination — as tensions rise with Mainland and Taiwan’s government questions the spouses’ allegiances. For the two months she served before being forced out of the legislature, Li was the country’s only Mainland-born lawmaker who had immigrated to Taiwan by marriage.

“It’s only because of Taiwan which has this free and democratic system, and the Taiwan People’s Party which was willing to give a political newcomer a chance, that I could have this opportunity,” she told The Associated Press in July.

But now, fears of a military intervention by Beijing have complicated Taiwan’s policy toward spouses like Li. She is part of a diverse group that includes multiple generations, from those who married retired Chinese soldiers and came to Taiwan in search of better economic opportunity to a younger, more educated and wealthier group that met after both sides relaxed their borders.

70 years of silence drive the issue

China and Taiwan split during a civil war in 1949, with the Nationalist Party fleeing to the island. For decades, the two sides banned all contact, until 1987 when Taiwan’s residents were allowed to visit their family members in the mainland for the first time. Tensions have fluctuated, but have been high since independence-leaning Tsai Ing-wen was elected in 2016, and Beijing cut off official contact.

Today, mainland China sends military planes and navy ships toward Taiwan daily as part of military exercises. It has also stepped up its diplomatic campaign to isolate the island on the international stage, poaching allies, keeping Taiwan out of international organizations.

That threat is raising fears on the island about who’s loyal to Taiwan. A New Taipei court sentenced Hsu Chun-ying, head of an organization dedicated to helping spouses, to seven years in prison Tuesday for acting on Beijing’s behalf to spy on Taiwan and interfere with its politics.

Mainland spouses were brides of soldiers

Mi Zhengrong, 72, met her husband through relatives in Hubei province.

Her husband was one of the veterans of the civil war who had fled to Taiwan and later were allowed back into the mainland to visit their hometowns for the first time. Many of them had been unable to marry in Taiwan and brought back women from China. Mi and her husband got married and lived in China, but her husband missed Taiwan — so they moved to the island in 2002. Her husband passed away after 12 years together.

She then married a neighbor in Taiwan, and they were together for nearly a decade. For the last two years, she said, he was paralyzed, and she had to take care of him round-the-clock.

Mi is now fighting to get her second husband’s pension, for which she would be eligible if they’ve been married for 10 years. But he passed away 13 days before they met that threshold. The military initially gave her the pension, but took it away after they realized the marriage fell short. Mi lives on about 10,000 New Taiwan dollars a month ($330), of which about a third goes to rent.

Still, she said, she prefers Taiwan.

Taiwan’s government had been changing laws to integrate the community into society by shortening the time it takes for them to get Taiwanese citizenship and allowing them to work.

Now, the island is scaling back the integration of “mainland spouses.” Last spring, Taiwan’s government deported three women who had advocated on social media for reunification by force.

Taiwan’s Mainland Affairs Council, which governs the island’s relationship with Beijing, said the women represented “repeated threats to Taiwan’s national security and social stability.”

Taiwanese immigration authorities also issued a notice to some 12,000 spouses who already held Taiwanese citizenship to provide proof they canceled their household registrations in mainland China or have their citizenship revoked.

Who can stay — and serve

Li, the former legislator, came into office in February with the Taiwan People’s Party to intense opposition.

Taiwan’s interior minister said Li could not serve as a legislator because she did not submit paperwork showing she renounced her Chinese citizenship. The Mainland Affairs Council said she did not submit documentation in time to show she had only a single nationality for the previous 10 years. Li argues she has held Taiwanese citizenship since 1999 and canceled her Chinese household registration then, thereby meeting the requirements.

With the sides still at an impasse in April, Li’s party expelled her. The government then toughened standards Chinese-born legislators must meet. “There’s no political consideration here,” a spokesperson for the Mainland Affairs Council said in defending the decision.

Some scholars, though, say that Taiwan’s government is enforcing the law selectively.

“The government these few years, they are interpreting many of the laws wrongly, or in a distorted way,” said Bruce Liao, a law professor and expert in immigration law at National Chengchi University.

“You can’t move against the Mainland,” he added. “But you can bully the ‘mainland spouses’ here, and use them to create hostility.”

Others defend the approach as a national security matter.

“The government has a compelling interest in protecting the safety of the country,” said Yen-Tu Su, a researcher at Academia Sinica in Taiwan. “And so usually the government would have some leeway in determining whether a foreign resident is a threat to the social order or safety of the society.”

Mainland spouses are treated differently

Even before recent controversies, spouses born in mainland China were treated differently from spouses born anywhere else. For example, “mainland spouses” can apply for Taiwanese citizenship after six years, while foreign spouses can apply in four years. They also must be Taiwanese citizens for 10 years before they can apply for government jobs, while foreign spouses can apply for most lower-level government jobs right after becoming citizens.

Behind the difference in law is a question of loyalty. Shangguanluan, a Chinese writer and activist who is known professionally by her pen name, moved to Taiwan in 2021 with her Taiwanese husband. She said she’s constantly plagued by such questions — whether she is acting on orders from the Chinese Communist Party, for example, or whether she’s a spy.

She acknowledged that Beijing is actively looking for targets, but said spouses were hardly ideal.

“If they want some core secrets, the people who are most convenient targets for them, are people who are closest to the secrets, in Taiwan’s defense, or in tech,” she said, such as “Taiwanese businessmen, or academics, or some institutional head.”

But on the list of valuable targets for information, “there’s no room for ‘mainland spouses.’” HUIZHONG WU, TAIPEI, MDT/AP